Are you trying to find the best way to take your crawl space from damp and musty to cool and ventilated? Then the comparison in this article will help you decide whether a fan or a dehumidifier is the solution.

Fan Dehumidifier
Less expensive to runMore expensive to run
Low installation cost Higher installation cost
More economic long-term maintenance Pricier long-term maintenance
Does not remove humidity Most effective solution to remove humidity

Is the humidity in your crawl space becoming a problem? Then find out which ventilation method will be best for your home in this article.

Choosing Between a Fan and a Dehumidifier

Making your crawl space a healthy environment is a tricky feat. In the summer, the humidity in the atmosphere leads to damp and mold spore growth. In the winter, the moisture in the air leads to more dampness and, you’ve guessed it, more mold spore growth. What can you do to stop the trend?

It is super important for you to install a ventilation system in your crawl space. And today, we will be considering the pros and cons of the two most popular solutions out there. Those are fans and dehumidifiers. You can find out which will be best for your home thanks to the upcoming comparison.

Fan

Are you thinking of installing a fan to ventilate your crawl space? Then we’ll consider a couple of instances where a fan may be the best choice for your home. Everything you need to know about fans and crawl spaces is coming right up.

Running Costs

When compared to the dehumidifier, a fan is the cheapest to run. The fans that are installed in crawl spaces use low voltage technology. So, you can expect your utility bill to rise slightly after installation. But you’ll be happy to know that the price difference will not break the bank.

Installation

Regardless of whether you are fitting a fan or a dehumidifier, you will have to modify your crawl space. But fitting a fan will require considerably less work. How much work?

To fit a fan, you will need stalked liners to cover the crawl space. But that is all. The fan won’t require any extra installation. It is much simpler to install a fan than it is a dehumidifier.

Long-Term Maintenance

What about running your fan for the long haul? The great thing about fans is that they are inexpensive to replace. Finding spare parts for them is usually cheap and simple. So, if you are making your choice based on the ease of long-term maintenance, a fan is the best option.

small-fan
Basement fans are low maintenance

Efficiency

In my point of view, efficiency is key. So, it doesn’t matter how cheap something is, if it doesn’t work, it doesn’t work. What can we say about the efficiency of a fan in a crawl space?

A fan may not be the most efficient ventilation solution for your crawl space if you live in a particularly damp or humid environment. This is because a fan will only circulate the air around the crawl space. So, if the air in the space is humid and moist, it will only push humid and moist air around. It will not remove the moisture from the air.

The efficiency of the fan depends on your environment. It all comes down to the relative humidity in your crawl space. Once the humidity in the air rises above 60% in the crawl space, you are creating the perfect breeding ground for mold spores.

But it is not just mold that you will have to worry about. The humidity can be the catalyst for more problems like these:

  • Floor joists and hardwood rotting and buckling
  • An 18% less energy-efficient home
  • Cold floors and damp in the winter

Dehumidifier

So, we’ve chatted a lot about fans, but what about dehumidifiers? In which instances could one be the best option for your home?

Running Costs

When comparing the dehumidifier to the fan, the dehumidifier is the most expensive to run. In fact, they can increase your utility bills anywhere between 10 and 50 dollars per month. For some homeowners, this is just too much of a monthly shell out for a room that no one will see or use.

Modification Costs

Before you can get your dehumidifier up and running, there is a lot of work that you will need to do. What kind of costs do you have to think about? Here are just some of them.

  • Professional installation
  • Encapsulating the crawl space. That is sealing off any gaps from the crawl space to outside. This also includes the following:
    • Closing off all the vents and drafts
    • Solving drainage problems
    • Cleaning contaminants from the space
  • Reinforcing the crawl space with fiber liners and extra insulation. This often needs sealing too.
  • HVAC upgrades encapsulate the crawl space to meet health and safety standards

You’ve guessed it. Modifying a crawl space to accommodate a dehumidifier is more expensive than modifying it to fit a fan.

crawl space under house
Your crawl space will need to be encapsulated to accommodate a dehumidifier

Long-Term Maintenance

When installing a ventilation system for your crawl space, there are a lot of costs to consider. One of them that hurts the most however is long-term maintenance. How much will it cost you to run a dehumidifier in the long run?

Running a dehumidifier will cost more than running a fan. This is because dehumidifiers themselves are more expensive. And when something goes wrong with them, they are not cheap to repair. Spare parts are pricey and their installation is too.

What if your dehumidifier needs replacing? To buy a new dehumidifier for a small crawl space, you are looking to spend about $200/$300. But a dehumidifier for a larger space will set you back a lot more.

repairing-dehumidifer
A dehumidifier will need regular maintenance

Efficiency

Up until now, you may wonder if there are any instances where the dehumidifier comes out on top when compared to a fan. But there are when you consider its efficiency. A dehumidifier will get the job done better than a fan. Now, you may be thinking, well, that’s a rather sweeping statement. So, take a look at what I’m basing this on.

Unlike a fan, a dehumidifier will do more than circulate air around the crawl space. It works to remove moisture from the air.

When you have a dehumidifier installed, the crawl space is modified. This is so that outside air cannot infiltrate the space. This means that the cold and damp air in the winter will not enter the crawl space. This will help you prevent a whole host of problems such as these:

  • Cold flooring and drafts in the winter
  • Expensive utility bills
  • Floors and beams buckling from a damp basement environment

What problems will it help you avoid in the summer? When you install a dehumidifier, the humid air is blocked from entering the crawl space. All of this keeps the environment at bay and means that the dehumidifier does not need to work as hard. The dehumidified environment cuts down on odors and helps to keep the house fresh.

Conclusion

So, we’ve seen a lot about the differences between fans and dehumidifiers. But which is the one for you? You should choose a fan if:

  • You are searching for a solution with the cheapest running costs
  • You want a ventilation system with the most economical installation
  • You are looking for an easy and inexpensive long-term maintenance plan

You should choose a dehumidifier if:

  • You are looking for the best solution to take humidity out of your crawl space even in humid or damp climates

Has this article been helpful to you? Then why not check out some of our other articles and free guides? You could even sign up to our email list.

Have a great day!

-Craig